absolute justice Essay - 1029 Words

Does absolute justice exist or not? This essay will present arguments for the existence of absolute justice. Many people disagree that absolute justice exists. Thus they argue that justice cannot be derived from nature since contradictory and different forms of justice exist in nature; and one cannot derive the greater and perfect from the lesser and imperfect, also they argue that the idea of absolute justice is the ideas of different cultures and times. That is why the idea of justice varies greatly from one culture to the next. The argument used to disprove the above statements will stem from the relationship of order to justice. The next paragraphs will present the arguments above. Culture and philosophy have always gone hand in hand.†¦show more content†¦That is obviously an imperfect justice, for the just and correct are not always the stronger. Or justice is perhaps helping friends and harming enemies, like a group of animals that cannot hunt on their own. Thus we see many different forms of justice in nature. Certainly justice cannot have different definitions. For instance if justice is in the interests of the stronger it cannot be helping friends and harming the enemies. (E.g. if ones friend is ones enemy, than one is helping ones enemy while the other is acting in their own interest even if it means your demise.) Not to mention that these forms of justice are of a lesser and inferior origin than the absolute justice. One from the lesser and inferior cannot derive the greater and perfect, only vis versa. Example: if one says that it is raining in Chelsea it does not mean that it is raining everywhere in the world. The simple existence of a lesser justice does not in any manner prove the existence of a greater or absolute justice. To disprove both of these arguments separately would require a lengthy discussion each piece. Rather an attempt will be made here to summarize both arguments without making them look like a red herring. 1. Since there are many different forms of justice found in nature and society there couldn’t be only one form of justice. 2.one cannot prove the greater from the lesser justice.Show MoreRelatedHardin s Lifeboat Analogy : An Interesting Situation1475 Words   |  6 Pageswith 50 people on board and a capacity of 60 floated past 100 other people in the water, who would we take, if anyone? If we tried to take everyone, the boat would capsize and everyone would either become stranded or die. It would lead to â€Å"complete justice, complete catastrophe† (Hardin 1). If we took no one, we would constantly have to stave off desperate people climbing on board and those who claim entitlement. If we decide to push our lifeboat to its limits, and add 10 more people, how would we chooseRead MoreWas absolute monarch the foundation of Democracy?900 Words   |  4 PagesWas absolute monarch the foundation of Democracy? In today’s world, there are several types of governments that control their countries. There are democracies, dictatorships, republics, monarchies etc. Absolute monarchy was a very common form of government centuries ago. Throughout this time period, many leaders, dictators, monarchs made mistakes that the government looks at today. The abuse and misuse of power by absolute monarchs inexorably led to the rise of modern democracy. This is shown throughRead MoreThe Prince And His Power1675 Words   |  7 Pagesview on the issue of the prince and his power called absolutism. Absolutism or absolute monarchy meant that the sovereign power or ultimate authority in the state rested in the hands of a king who claimed to rule by divine right- the king received their power from God and were responsible to no one except God (Spielvogel p. 362). In an absolute monarchy, the king had the authority to make laws, taxes, administer justice, determine foreign policy, and controlled the state’s administrative system. TheRead MorePolitical Systems Thematic Essay1536 Words   |  7 PagesHistory and culture of many nations and societies have been affected by political systems. In the 1600s-1700s two political systems, absolute monarchy of France and the constitutional monarchy of England, have affected Europe. Absolute monarchy is when a ruler rules with absolute, or total, power. A constitutional monarchy is when laws limit the power of the monarch so they cannot rule absolutely. These two political systems affected not only their own country, but the whole of Europe as well. MainlyRead MoreThe Proper Role of a Ruler and the Government Essay1509 Words   |  7 Pageslonger possesses the authority or the legitimacy to rule them. Furthermore, John Locke highlights another critical matter: that absolute power should never be attained by a ruler because such rule may only lead to consequences of disadvantage to the people. He states, â€Å"Whensoever [...] the legislature shall [...] grasp themselves, or put into the hands of any other, an absolute power over their lives, liberties, and estates of the people, by this breach of trust they forfeit the power the people hadRead MoreThe Absolute And Constitutional Governments During The Seventeenth Century Essay1685 Words   |  7 Pagesthese key figures tried to dominate the government under absolute authority their control was still limited. Absolutists monarchies were trying to be established all over the country, unfortunately many of them failed due to various factors. Throughout the se venteenth century Europe rulers have tried to maintain an absolutist monarchy however society still found some holes in their power, which limited the ruler’s control. The absolute and constitutional governments were two very different governmentsRead MoreThe Rise of the Sovereignty of the Peoples of Europe and the Americas1758 Words   |  7 PagesRight of Kings, the right to rule over the people came directly from God and not from the people. Jacques-Benigne Bossuet, one of the greatest preachers of the seventeenth century, claimed that royal authority, which is given by God, is paternal, absolute, and invincible. During the heyday of this theory, most people believed in a supreme God who had created the universe, and thus, seeing kings as divine creatures chosen by God to rule over His earth seemed logical. Jacques-Benigne Bossuet claimedRead MoreThomas Hobbes And The Philosophy Of Political Science1729 Words   |  7 Pagescreatures and would do anything to better their position and social status. These people, when left alone will go back to their evil impulses to get a better advantage over others. So Thomas Hobbes concluded that the best form of government would an absolute monarchy, which is a government which gives all power to the king or queen to provide direction and leadership to make sure the country doesn’t go into turmoil. To support his ideas, Thomas Hobbes asked the question,† If men are naturally in a stateRead MoreThe French Revolution Was An Era Where There Was A Dramatic1342 Words   |  6 PagesThe French Revolution was an era where there was a dramatic political and social change. The supporters of the French Revolution came across problems such as women s lack of a right to citizenship, Absolute Monarchy of the Feudal System, and the lack of rights of the clergy and nobility. The supporters of the French Revolution attempted to solve these problems by abolishing the Feudal system, and the establishment of a republic. They also created steps towards resolving the lack of women’s rightsRead MoreThe Philosophy Of Political Science1799 Words   |  8 Pagesthat questioned by stating that since people were naturally wicked and shouldn’t become trusted to govern themselves because they were selfish creatures and would do anything to better their position and social status, it would be best to have an absolute monarchy, which would stop the people when left alone to go back to their own evil impulse to be led into the right direction and leadership to make sure the country doesn’t go into turmoil. To support this viewpoint, Thomas Hobbes asked